Question: What philosophy counters or disagrees with Ayn Rand and Objectivism, and what are some good books outlining these differences?
Answer: Ayn Rand
was a radical thinker, i.e., one who went to the root of long-standing philosophical problems. She was self-consciously opposed to many of the ideas of most of the well-developed Western philosophical traditions ( such as Platonism, Kantianism, German Idealism, Pragmatism, Humean Empiricism, and Existentialism). As an advocate of objectivity and rational selfishness she was opposed to the key teachings of virtually all religions.
Read our Q&A archive
online to see some of the contrasts (I could not even scratch the surface here). To go more in depth read "This is John Galt Speaking" or "For the New Intellectual" in the book of that name by Ayn Rand
for Objectivist attacks on prominent views. Nathaniel Branden's "The Moral Revolution in Atlas Shrugged
" is another good source, as is my own "Radical for Capitalism." I also have an introductory course, "The Essence of Objectivism
," on CD, that contrasts Objectivism
with many prominent ideas. (All the above are available from The Objectivism Store.
A number of books sharply critical of Objectivism
have been published over the years (all these can be researched through the Objectivism Reference Center
, which has the critics links). Several are by Christians of a certain stripe, including books by John Robbins and Michael Yang. "The Philosophic Thought of Ayn Rand
" by Douglas Rasmussen and Douglas Den Uyl contains philosophical critiques of Objectivism
of varying quality. "The Ayn Rand
Cult" by Jeff Walker collects every attack or scurrilous rumor and slings every bit of mud against Objectivism
as can be found. It's a self-contradictory and sloppily researched hash, but it serves up of plenty of vitriol, if that's what you are looking for. None of the book-length criticisms of Objectivism
I am aware of is good: none combines basic standards of scholarship and a sound understanding of Objectivism
with a basically rational approach to criticism.
William R Thomas has written on topics in politics, ethics, and epistemology, and has spoken internationally on the theory of individual rights and Ayn Rand’s philosophy of Objectivism. His works include Radical for Capitalism, and, as editor, The Literary Art of Ayn Rand. He is the director of programs for The Atlas Society. Thomas is currently a lecturer in the Department of Economics of the University at Albany.